Cost Analysis of Low RPM 60-80 RPM 35kW AC Generators

The cost of a low RPM 60-80 RPM, 35kW AC generator can vary significantly based on the specifications and the design complexity. These generators are specialized and can be quite expansive. Let's dive into the details and examine the cost considerations.

The Cost of Low RPM Generators

When it comes to low RPM generators, the cost can be quite high due to the specialized nature and the size required to produce the necessary power. A good example is a 250 RPM, 5kW generator, which my friend purchased for more than USD5,000. For a 35kW generator operating at 60-80 RPM, the cost could be much higher due to the large size and engineering required.

For power output less than MW capacity, stepping up the prime mover RPM via belts and pulleys or transmission gears can significantly reduce the cost. By increasing the prime mover RPM from the low range to around 500 RPM, the generator's poles can be increased to six pairs. This approach results in an expected loss of output around 3-5%, depending on the design of the RPM stepping mechanism. However, the overall cost of the generator will drop considerably.

Engine Selection and Cost

Regarding the power source for a 35kW generator, diesel engines that can supply the necessary power, such as those used in ships, are the most feasible options. These engines typically operate at about 120 RPM, making 60-80 RPM about half speed. While the cost of these engines remains unknown, they would be significant due to their specialized nature and the materials required.

Custom-Designed High RPM Generators

Custom-designed generators with a high RPM of 1500 RPM for a 35kW output can be more affordable but require a significant investment. These units often have a massive diameter, more than a thousand poles, and a heavy shaft and bearing. The cost could easily be in the range of hundreds of thousands of dollars due to the need for precision engineering and the custom manufacturing process.

Utilizing Gearboxes for Cost Efficiency

One way to reduce the cost of low RPM generators is by using a gearbox. A gearbox can significantly reduce the size of the generator. The gearbox transfers torque from the low-speed shaft of the prime mover to the high-speed shaft of the generator. Traditionally, a gearbox has not been required, as the low-speed shaft could drive the generator directly. However, the use of a gearbox allows for smaller, more affordable generators to be employed.

The high-speed shaft of the generator delivers power to the generator at approximately 1500 RPM, with the gearbox transmission ratio being around 1:100. This reduces the size and weight of the generator, making it more practical and cost-effective. It is important to note that without a gearbox, a low-speed generator would be heavier and more expensive than the combination of a gearbox and a high-speed generator.

While 1 RPM per second (60-80 RPM) seems low for a motor or generator, it is often feasible with specialized machinery designed for such applications. The key factors in the design and manufacturing process dictate the overall cost and feasibility.

Final Considerations

In conclusion, the cost of a low RPM 60-80 RPM, 35kW AC generator is significantly higher due to the specialized design and large size required. However, by stepping up the RPM and utilizing a gearbox, the overall cost can be reduced. Understanding the specific requirements and considerations is crucial for cost-effective and efficient power generation.

Keywords

low RPM generator cost, 60-80 RPM 35kW AC generator, generator pricing