Is Grammarly Pro Worth the Cost in 2024? A Fiction Writer's Perspective

In the realm of fiction writing, do grammar checkers like Grammarly Pro add value, or do they hinder the creative process? This article explores whether Grammarly Pro justifies its cost, focusing on the unique challenges faced by fiction writers.

The Limitations of Grammar Checkers

Grammar checkers are a staple for many writers, but they are not a one-size-fits-all solution, especially for fiction. When we say, “Oh no Grammarly Pro says this is a FRAGMENT SENTENCE can’t have THAT,” we often dismiss our own artistic judgment without a second thought. Did we notice the previous sentence contained a comma splice? If yes, why do we need a grammar checker? If no, do you think removing that comma splice would improve the sentence? These questions highlight the necessity of developing your own judgment and understanding when it comes to effective writing.

Challenges with Grammar Checkers in Fiction Writing

Fiction is about more than just producing technically correct sentences; it's about telling a compelling story. Do you think a grammar checker should dictate the use of passive voice or whether a character should say “Whoops maybe we hadn’t ought to of done that?rdquo; If you take grammar checkers too seriously, your writing might become bland and predictable, rather than engaging and unique. Using your own artistic judgment is pivotal in ensuring that your writing resonates with readers.

Modern Grammar Checkers and Their Limitations

Modern grammar checkers like GrammarPro have improved significantly over time. For instance, the new special autopredict function is widely considered to be absolutely horrible. You can disable this feature in the advanced options menu and should consider doing so if you're writing fiction. The grammar checker is still incorrect a lot of the time when it comes to effective writing rather than correct writing.

The real issue lies in the frequency and usefulness of the suggestions. The grammar checker may still offer a lot of nitpicking advice that, while technically correct, can undermine the narrative flow. Turning off certain checks and focusing on the essential suggestions can help you write more effectively and retain your creative vision.

Benefits of the Free Version for Fiction Writers

Even the free version of Grammar Pro can be quite useful for fiction writers. As a native speaker, I find it works fine for catching actual grammar or spelling errors in informal messages. It likely catches about 90 to 95 percent of the actual issues you'd consider in everyday writing. However, when it comes to more formal or creative writing, you'll need to tailor the settings and use your judgment.

Developing both a feel for correct grammar and when not to use it is crucial. Fiction is about creating a living, breathing world and characters. The correct usage of grammar in the service of this goal is what truly matters.

Fiction writers should focus on their own artistic judgment and not rely solely on software. While a grammar checker can be a helpful tool, it should be used in conjunction with your own instincts and creativity. This balance is key to producing compelling, engaging fiction.