Is the GTX 750 Ti with an i5 4590 Better than the AMD 2400G APU?

When considering the choice of a graphics card or an all-in-one APU (Accelerated Processing Unit), the question of whether the GTX 750 Ti paired with an Intel i5 4590 is superior to the AMD 2400G can be quite complex. This article delves into the pros and cons of both setups, examining their performance in gaming and general usage, to help you make an informed decision.

Performance and Efficiency

The main factor in this comparison is the balance between performance and power consumption. The Intel i5 4590 and the AMD 2400G each come with unique advantages and limitations.

The Intel i5 4590 is an 84W CPU, while the AMD 2400G is a 65W APU (Accelerated Processing Unit). When combined with a GTX 750 Ti, you have a total power consumption of 144W. This means that the GTX 750 Ti with the i5 4590 setup will consume more power compared to the 2400G alone. However, the increased power also allows for higher performance, especially in gaming.

The power consumption difference is notable, but it's crucial to weigh the benefits against your energy efficiency goals and your hardware budget. If you prioritize performance above all else, the GTX 750 Ti with the i5 4590 will undoubtedly offer better gaming performance, even if it consumes more power.

Gaming Performance

For gaming purposes, the GTX 750 Ti with the i5 4590 is likely to outperform the AMD 2400G. This is because the GTX 750 Ti is a dedicated graphics card designed for high-performance gaming, while the 2400G is optimized for integrated graphics on a budget. The i5 4590, though an older model, still has the ability to handle demanding games at mid-to-high settings, especially when paired with the GTX 750 Ti.

During benchmarking, the GTX 750 Ti with the i5 4590 consistently outperformed the 2400G. The 750 Ti can handle modern games at 1080p or even 1440p at decent settings, whereas the 2400G is limited by its integrated graphics. For older games or at lower resolutions, the 2400G might seem competitive, but for the best gaming experience, the GTX 750 Ti with the i5 4590 is the clear choice.

General Usage

For general usage, the AMD 2400G can be quite effective. Its integrated graphics and lower power consumption make it an excellent choice for office work, web browsing, and basic multimedia tasks. The 2400G's 65W APU design means that it operates more quietly and efficiently than the 84W i5 4590.

The only real upgrade path for the i5 4590 and GTX 750 Ti is through more powerful parts, which can be expensive. In contrast, the 2400G offers a straightforward path to upgrading to newer models with integrated GPUs, making it a more cost-effective solution in the long run.

Conclusion

Neither setup reigns supreme across all scenarios, but the choice depends on your priorities. If you prioritize gaming performance and are willing to spend more on power consumption, the GTX 750 Ti with the i5 4590 is the better option. However, if you need a more power-efficient and cost-effective solution with a clear upgrade path, the AMD 2400G is a more suitable choice.

Ultimately, the decision should be based on your specific needs and budget. The GTX 750 Ti with the i5 4590 will provide better gaming performance, while the 2400G is more efficient for general use with a clear upgrade path.