The Necessity of Retaining Older Technologies: A Case for Printed Books and Windows 7

Disruptive technologies often portray a story of gradual replacement or innovation that creates entirely new markets. However, sometimes, older technologies are unnecessarily replaced with more modern ones, which themselves work just as well. This article will explore the case for retaining printed books and the continued utility of Windows 7 as examples of older technologies that should not be discarded.

The Obsolescence Trap

The concept of obsolescence is a common phenomenon where technologies are prematurely replaced due to marketing hype or the push for newer, shinier alternatives. While breakthroughs and innovative applications have driven significant advancements, the notion that older technologies are inherently inferior or outdated is often misleading. This is evident in the case of welding, gluing, and riveting in the construction of metal parts, and the ongoing debate about whether modern digital technologies can fully replace traditional printed books and Windows 7.

Welding, Gluing, and Riveting: Evolution in Technology

The evolution of how metal parts are joined—from riveting to welding to gluing—has been a testament to the adaptability and resilience of older technologies. Each method has its strengths and applications, just like modern and traditional printed books and Windows 7. Riveting, used in the construction of structures like the Eiffel Tower, ensures a strong and durable connection, while welding offers a more seamless and modern aesthetic for high-sea drilling rigs.

The latest method, gluing, is employed in the aerospace industry for its precision and strength, ensuring the safety and functionality of fighter jets. This evolutionary shift showcases that newer technologies do not necessarily supplant older ones but rather coexist based on specific applications and requirements. Just like the choice between welding and gluing depends on the context, so too does the choice between modern and traditional printed books or operating systems.

The Case for Retaining Printed Books

While digital technologies offer convenience and interactivity, printed books still hold a unique and irreplaceable place in human culture. Modern printed books, with their high-quality typography, paper, and binding, offer an unparalleled reading experience. The tactile and aesthetic qualities of a physical book enhance the user's engagement and comprehension.

Take, for example, the difficulty of searching for a specific passage in a printed book versus a digital text. The pleasure of leafing through the pages, the scent of ink, and the feeling of the paper in your hands all contribute to a more immersive and reflective reading experience. In scenarios where deep reflection and self-reflection are required, such as for bildung (personal development and education), printed books offer advantages that digital counterparts cannot match.

The experience of reading a Gutenberg Bible or a rare incunabula compared to a modern printed book is akin to the difference between a digital and a physical library. The latter often lacks the personalized touch and historical significance that rare materials carry.

Windows 7: A Case Study in Technology Stability

Another example of an older technology that works fine but is often replaced is Windows 7. Despite the pressure from Microsoft to upgrade to Windows 10, Windows 7 continues to maintain a significant market share, with around 20% of operating system users. This enduring popularity is a testament to the reliability and user satisfaction offered by the older operating system.

Why Keep Windows 7?

The continued existence of Windows 7 is not just a matter of stability but also a pragmatic decision. Many organizations and individuals still rely on Windows 7 for its stability and the compatibility with older software and hardware. While Microsoft was initially considering dropping support, it ultimately decided to support it as a paid service for enterprise customers, demonstrating the value of maintaining older systems.

Conclusion

In the rapid evolution of technology, it is easy to overlook the benefits and merits of older technologies. Both printed books and Windows 7 exemplify the value of retaining such technologies, which continue to serve their purpose effectively. The decision to replace these technologies should be made carefully, considering the specific needs and benefits of the users. As with welding and gluing, each method has its place and purpose, and it is essential to recognize the unique contributions of these older technologies in our lives.