Why Does My New 2019 MacBook Keyboard Feel Different? Understanding the Butterfly and Scissor-Switch Mechanisms

Many users have noticed a difference in the typing sensation when switching from a 2015 MacBook to a 2019 model. This discrepancy is not an anomaly but a testament to the continuous evolution of technology aimed at solving issues faced by users with earlier models.

Evolution of the Butterfly Keyboard

The butterfly keyboard, introduced with the 2016 MacBook Pro models, was a significant upgrade. It aimed to address the issues faced by users with the clamshell lid design and the widely criticized scissor-switch keyboards of older models. However, the butterfly keyboard itself faced its own set of challenges. Users noticed that the new design caused a slight change in the keyboard's feel as updates were released.

2019 MacBook Series and the New Scissor-Switch Design

Introduced in 2019, the 16-inch MacBook Pro featured a more robust keyboard mechanism that shifted away from the butterfly design. The new scissor-switch keyboard, which is also used in the standalone Magic Keyboard, brings a different feel to the typing experience. This change was not just about aesthetics but also about performance and durability.

Differences Between the Butterfly and Scissor-Switch Mechanisms

To understand why the keyboard feels different, it's important to look at the two main types of keyboard designs: the butterfly and the scissor-switch. Here’s a detailed comparison:

The Butterfly Keyboard

The butterfly mechanism consists of a frame with four hinged plastic legs that lay flat when the key is not being pressed. These legs form a butterfly-like shape, hence the name. The butterfly keyboard design was intended to be more compact and efficient. However, it faced criticism for its susceptibility to dust and debris, making it sensitive to changes in temperature and humidity.

The Scissor-Switch Keyboard

In contrast, the scissor-switch mechanism features a more stable design with a cross-shaped spring mechanism. This design offers a more tactile and responsive typing experience, making it less prone to malfunctions due to dust or debris. The scissor-switch is also less sensitive to temperature changes, making it a more reliable option in varied environments.

Implications for User Experience

The transition from the butterfly keyboard to the scissor-switch design in the 2019 MacBook models significantly affected user experience. The change brought about a more stable and tactile typing sensation, which aligns more closely with the expectations of today's tech-savvy users. However, for those accustomed to the butterfly keyboard, the shift can feel jarring at first. It's essential to give your new keyboard some time to adjust, allowing you to appreciate the new design.

Care and Maintenance of Your 2019 MacBook Keyboard

To ensure optimal performance and longevity of your new scissor-switch keyboard, consider the following care and maintenance tips:

Use a soft, lint-free cloth to clean the keyboard regularly. Avoid using harsh chemicals or solvents as they can damage the keyboard. Clean underneath the keyboard to prevent dust accumulation, which can affect performance. Consider using a rugged keyboard protector if you use your MacBook in various environments.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is the butterfly keyboard on my 2015 MacBook the same as the one in my 2019 MacBook?

No, the butterfly keyboard went through several iterations and improvements, addressing the issues identified in earlier models. The keyboard in your 2019 MacBook may have a different feel due to these updates.

Why does my 2019 MacBook have a different keyboard mechanism?

The 2019 MacBook introduced the scissor-switch keyboard to improve stability, durability, and overall typing experience. This design shift was intended to address the limitations of the butterfly keyboard.

How can I make the shift to the new keyboard easier?

Giving your new keyboard some time to settle in can help you become accustomed to its feel. Regularly clean the keyboard to maintain its performance and consider a durable protective cover to shield it from damage in various settings.

Conclusion

The transition from the butterfly keyboard to the scissor-switch design in the 2019 MacBook marks a significant step in advancing user experience. While the change may feel different initially, it brings with it a more stable, responsive, and reliable typing experience. By understanding the differences and caring for your new keyboard properly, you can enjoy a superior typing experience with your new MacBook.